What blame? This is a meme not an analysis, it’s meant to challenge the viewer to no longer think in terms of “what can I get out of electoralism” and instead focus on the death and carnage that the false choice is meant to distract from but instead what keeps western societies running.
I apologize if my comment felt rude.
You literally said that it contained “grains of truth”, implying that it’s largely made up and then said I was just trying to push a specific narrative. That’s pretty rude if you ask me.
I don’t know exactly what you mean that Russia does “not care for it’s people”. The meme I posted is very clear that I’m critical of the exploitative system in Russia today. I don’t think anyone contends that the Russian government is doing such a costly military operation and eating all these sanctions just because they want to do what’s right for the people in the Donbas. I thought the comment I reposted actually laid the clear economic incentives for their actions out, and why I would consider it a defensive war. Ukraine suddenly getting much closer with NATO, getting into free trade agreements with the EU that endanger the Russian economy etc. Russia prior to that was pretty respectful of Ukraine’s sovereignty as far as I know, it was only when Ukraine made such a hard shift to the West and had russophobic paramilitary nazi troops launch a civil war on their border that they intervened, which seems like a pretty good reason to me? And they only intervened with aid and not directly at first, it was 5 years into an ongoing war that they actually got involved with their own military.
To me, if Russia’s aim had been to just grab as much of Ukraine as they want they would have done it sooner, and there would be other indications of this prior (like e.g. a free trade agreement and forcing them to take a loan like the EU does). I’m certainly not an expert on this which is why I copied someone elses comment and didn’t write my own, so if you have more information please do share.
While there are grains of truth in your argument you are trying to paint Russia as a defender of its people which it really isnt.
Unnecessary and rude. You said that you “cant see what west has to do with this conflict aside from providing aid to Ukraine”, well there you go. Now you see. This wasn’t even my comment, I just copy-pasted it because it looked like you wanted more info on this. If you have some facts to add please do.
I don’t understand how your thing about russia killing cattle relates to this. You say that they are “painting it as a measure to combat disease” suggesting you disagree with it but offer no alternative explanation. To me that just looks like you’re trying to paint russia as something by throwing out stuff unrelated to the discussion with some vague handwaving about why the official story is not believable.
deleted by creator
he whole Ukraine conflict goes back to 2013, when President Yanukovych was about to sign the EU Association Agreement which would be a stepping stone towards ascending to the EU. The far right Nazis hated Russia, obviously, so Ukraine joining the EU was a very big deal for them.
On the other hand, Russia (and Putin) had no problem with it, except for one part: Ukraine and Russia had tariff free agreement, and Ukraine signing the Association Agreement would complicate things.
Back in 2010, the Eurasian Customs Union was established and was composed of Russia, Belarus and Kazakhstan. It was an attempt to revive the Soviet era heavy industry chain in these post-Soviet states. It was also explicitly a customs union (as you can tell from the name), which means that it is a protectionist bloc that would help prevent foreign interference in the form of free trade arragements. Ukraine was also a country that was being courted by the Customs Union, because, well, it was a post-Soviet state and inherited some very advanced shipbuilding and aviation industrial capabilities.
The EU Association Agreement was a targeted attack against Russia’s Eurasian Customs Union. Unlike their Russian counterpart, the EU Association Agreement is explicitly a free trade agreement, which means that if Ukraine signed the agreement, it would not be allowed to join a customs union (protectionist bloc) in the future. Ukraine was forced into a dilemma where it could only choose one side: the EU or Russia.
This became a problem for Russia because Ukraine and Russia had existing tariff free agreement, and the free trade deal with the EU would allow European goods to enter Russian market without tariffs, but Russian goods cannot do the same against the European market. This was all made clear in Putin’s statements back in 2013, who explicitly said that this was an attempt to flood the Russian market with European goods to destroy its domestic industries.
However, Putin was not objecting to Ukraine joining the EU, he simply asked that the tariff issue be sorted and proposed a trilateral meeting between the EU, Ukraine and Russia to work out the specific details. The EU rejected Russia’s proposal, and pushed Yanukovych into committing to the deal. Again, forcing Ukraine to make a choice between the two.
Furthermore, the EU deal came with additional conditions: Ukraine would also have to commit to IMF loans and implement austerity (reduced spending on healthcare and education) as well as privatizing parts of their land (which had remained illegal in Ukraine even in the 2000s).
Around that time, Moscow also floated an alternative proposal that would have given Ukraine pretty much the same deal, but without the austerity part. Instead, Ukraine would actually get discounts on Russian energy.
President Yanukovych hesitated. Contrary to popular narrative, Yanukovych did not agree to a deal with Moscow. He had remained a pro-EU politician, and simply hesitated because the conditions were unfair to the Ukrainian people.
But that was already too much for the Banderites, who saw Yanukovych as betraying their cause, and set off the Maidan revolution by late 2013. Attacks and hostilities against ethnic Russians, who predominantly occupy the eastern regions of Ukraine (the Donbass and Crimea) ramped up.
On February 22nd, 2014, a coup was initiated and the far right nationalists took over the government. Yanukovych fled. The next day, on the February 23rd, the very first act of the coup regime was to repeal the Kivalov-Kolesnichenko Language Law, a 2012 law that granted official status to minority languages in the country, including the Russian language.
The act invoked strong condemnation from the ethnic Russians in the Donbass region, and seeing that an ethnic cleansing was about to take place, they rose up as a separatist movement against the Maidan coup regime. The Ukrainian civil war had erupted, and Russia - seeing that the ethnic Russians were about to be slaughtered - intervened. The rest is history.
For that, Russia would be subjected to an international sanction so deep that it would kill their economic growth for the next 4 years, and barely able to breathe when Covid hit in 2020.
Also, completely unrelated - the Nord Stream 1 pipeline, which guaranteed cheap natural gas supply to the EU, was commissioned in November 2011, just a little over two years before Maidan coup happened.
The problem with NATO came later after the Ukrainian fascists were defeated in the civil war, and paused with the Minsk Agreement. The fascists violated the truce fairly quickly, and were beaten again in 2015, and the Minsk II was forged, with German Chancellor Merkel and the French President Hollande giving their promises to Putin that Ukraine would take it seriously this time, for real.
Importantly, the Minsk Agreement would hand the Donbass back to the Ukraine authorities, under the condition that the local governments would be given the autonomy on cultural matters (such that Ukrainian politicians cannot simply ban the Russian language without the agreement of the local population). However, Russia would keep Crimea.
Ukraine never even bothered to adhere to the Minsk Agreement. Instead, over the next 7 years, they would be armed and trained by NATO, and reformed the Ukrainian Armed Forces to a formidable fighting force. Implicit (and not so implicit) in Ukraine’s actions showed that they intended to retake Donbass and Crimea by force. Putin continued to wait.
By 2019, President Zelensky was elected as a peace president with popular support from the ethnic Russian heavy regions (not part of the separatist state). However, when Biden took office in early 2021, a visit to the White House completely changed Zelensky’s outlook, and he went back on his promise to bridge the divide between ethnic Ukrainians and Russians. Instead, his rhetoric changed significantly and teased about joining NATO.
This raised the alarm on the Russian front, and resulted in the US-Russia Summit in June 2021, when the Russian side prepared hundreds of pages of proposal on the various scenarios for de-escalation. The Americans ignored Russian concern, and in August 2021, and then again in December 2021, the US sent Javelins and Stingers to the Ukrainian side, further flaming the tension.
By early February 2022, the Ukrainian military had been mobilized, and artillery shelling into the separatist territory ramped up by an order of magnitude. Russia made its move.
Also, another yet completely unrelated incident - Nord Stream 2 pipeline completed its construction in 2021, and was awaiting commission at the time the war broke out.
Probably the thing he did for the >20 years prior to that?
open modlog
hoo boy yeah good riddance I’d say
Just make accounts wherever and stick with the one that you like the most tbh. That’s the beauty of the fediverse, the many options can seem daunting but you don’t have to choose one! I have this account to interact with lemmy.ml directly, I have a blahaj account to interact with the wider fediverse while getting transphobes and the worst of the reactionaries filtered I have a hexbear account to interact with hexbear. I like the hexbear community the most, it’s probably the most one that is a community within itself with multiple sub-communities but it’s of course a matter of taste. The most choice you get from lemmy.zip I believe which is the most widely federated one and stays out of drama. There is dbzer0 the more anarchist oriented instance. Lemmy.world is the most reddit one I feel like both in tone and moderation. But just make acounts wherever it doesn’t matter.
That is pretty uncalled for
Oh that’s a macaco-inglês. Which means “english monkey” so called because it looks a lot like english people.
Oh darn i mixed up the papers 😳 good catch
Ominous…😶
deleted by creator
yes
lol the guy shuttered his instance and only links to
This is his at least second dramatic exit from lemmy https://lemmy.zip/post/43721937
Only if you promise not to leave me 🥹
Well it’s not addressed at liberals or conservatives but people who identify as leftists but still believe in the electoralist/reformist path. Only a few people on lemmy identify as liberal and even fewer as conservative.
Failing that, it’s just a meme. I don’t see any harm in posting it even if it doesn’t have the intended effect.
edit: you know the kind of people already fed up with the fakeness of it, seemingly having to support the palestinian genocide for instance no matter how they choose, but can’t quite put their finger on what’s wrong with the system.